For ahmedjbh: Shia scholars and Aisha (RA)

[zaid_ibn_ali]

Any comments on this ahmedjbh?

Warning, this will make any true muslim's blood boil.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SOcoFZVhf80&feature=related

Oh & I notice it says that Yasir Al Habib lives in London now. Would love to see him open his mouth round the ends lol...

[ahmedjbh]

this has always been exposed and answered, please use the search feature, we cant keep refuting the same lies every week.

[Madarijas-Salikeen]

never straight answers from the shia

[zaid_ibn_ali]

apologies if the thread has been done before. I've searched and couldnt find the refutation. Any links ahmedjbh?

[ahmedjbh]

yer here

http://forums.islamicawakening.com/showthread.php?t=7568&highlight=shia+video

just search for shia and video and it comes up several times.

[zaid_ibn_ali]

ahmedjbh:

look at the video I posted again. Tell me whether 'Ayatollah' Shirazi did or didnt say those things? You can say Yasir Al Habib is a renegade, and I agree he seems a nobody, but what about your grand 'ayatollah' Shirazi?

[hearandobey]

ahmedjbh:

look at the video I posted again. Tell me whether 'Ayatollah' Shirazi did or didnt say those things? You can say Yasir Al Habib is a renegade, and I agree he seems a nobody, but what about your grand 'ayatollah' Shirazi?

there's even proof that shirazi says these kind of things in his own website.

[leo]

ahmedjbn do you know about the forward block of your Imam site (shiachat).

Look at them shia vs shia :D

http://shiachatgo.2hell.com/

[ahmedjbh]

Shirazi is not the most mainstream scholar, but I have seen no evidence to say that he has said the words that are in the video, in fact I remeber seeing the video in a completely different topic, so im guessing someone has just added the voice.

You can tell its added as the words dont match his mouth moving at all.

[ahmedjbh]

leo,

is that where you get all your info from?

lol.

[leo]

No, just wanted to let you know that some shia consider your Imam site as one of the biggest fitnah :D

[zaid_ibn_ali]

Shirazi is not the most mainstream scholar, but I have seen no evidence to say that he has said the words that are in the video, in fact I remeber seeing the video in a completely different topic, so im guessing someone has just added the voice.

You can tell its added as the words dont match his mouth moving at all.


look carefully. The voice transmission maybe slightly out of sync, as happens with alot of streams, but the voice does match his mouth movement. Sometimes its may be delayed, but hear what was said and see his mouth movement after, it defo fits.

So dont try using that as an excuse:)

Oh and having read more about this evil man, he clearly had a high standing amongst shi'ites globally.

[ahmedjbh]

the current main shia scholars are Sestani, Fadlullah, Khamenei.

The current Shirazi is not as popular as his previous family members.

Why dont you go and actually read the shia version of events, before we comment on some propaganda.

http://al-islam.org/fatimahrolemodel/

[Abu Malik al-Maliki]

Oh & I notice it says that Yasir Al Habib lives in London now. Would love to see him open his mouth round the ends lol...

loll

hahahaha