PDA

View Full Version : Menstruation and postnatal bleeding part 1


Abu Faaris As-Sumalee
11th August 2006, 01:06 AM
From the treatise of Shaykh salih al-Fawzan based on Ar-Rawdul-murbi fi sharh zadul-mustaqni

Bismilahi ar-rahminir-rahim

Menstruation is the flow of a type of natural blood from the womb at specific times. the blood is habitually discharged every month for six or seven days, and the period can be more or less than that. In other words , a womans monthly period can be longer or shorter depending on the different nature of each woman predetermined by Allah.


RULINGS STATED IN THE NOBLE QURAN AND SUNNAH CONCERNING MENSTRUATION

It is prohibited for a menstruating women either to perform prayer or observe fasting, as the prophet (saw) said to fatimah bint abu hubaysh:
"Give up prayer when your menstrual period begins"1

Thus, the prayer and fasting of mensturating women are deemed invalid,as the prophet(saw) has prohibited that 2, and the prophets prohibition means it is invalid to perform what he has prohibited. therefore, a woman who performs such acts of worship in that state of impurity is considerd to be disobedient to allah and his messenger(saw)

When the menstrual period is over, a woman has to make up for the missed days of fasting according to the juristic consensus, with out making up for the prayers that she has missed. A'ishah (ra) said:
"When we menstruated during the life of Allah's menssenger(saw),we used to be commanded (by Allah's Messenger) to make up for the missed days of fasting, but we were not orderd to make up for the missed days of prayer, but we were not ordered to make up for the missed prayers" (bukhari and muslim) 3

It is impermissible for a menstuating women to make tawaf (going round the ka'bah), to recite the noble quran, or to stay in a mosque, in addition, it is prohibited for her husband to have sexual intercourse with her until her period is over and she takes a ritual bath. Allah, exalted be he, says:
"And they ask you about menstruation. Say, it is harm, so keep away from wives during menstuation. And do not approach them until they are pure. And when they have purified themselves, then come to them from wher Allah has ordained for you..."Quan:AL-Baqarah:222

The phrase "...keep away from wives during menstruation" means not to have sexual intercourse with them within that period. the prophet(saw) also said:
"You can do everything (with your wives during mensturation) exept sexual intercourse."4

It is permissible for the husband of menstruating woman to enjoy her by kissing , touching and the like, except for having sexual intercourse with her.
It is impermissible for the husband of a menstruating woman to divorce her before her menstrual period is over, as Allah says:

"]"O prophet, when you (muslims) divorce women, divorce them at (the comencement of ) their waiting period..." [/B]AT-Talaq :1

That is , when they become pure ?(from mestruation , sexual intercourse, etc.) Also , the prophet (saw) ordered a man who had divorced his wife during her menstrual period to take her back and to divorce her( if he realy wanted to)when her period was over.

Once the menstural blood stops discharging, a women becomes pure and her menstrual period is deemed over. She must then take a ritual bath, after which she is allowed to do whatever act of worship which wer prohibited for her during menstuation. After blood stops discharging, a women becomes pure and her menstrual period is deemed over. She must then take a ritual bath, after which she is allowed to do whatever acts of worship which were prohibited for her during menstruation. After blood stops discharging , a woman does not have to be concerend about any secretion or yellowish discharge, as indicated in the hadith narrated on the authority of umm 'Atiyyah (may Allah be pleased with her) who said: "We never considered yellowish dischaarge as a thing of importance ( as menstruation)"this hadith is related by al-bukhari and other compilers fo hadith 5, and it is deemed a marfu (traceable) hadith, for the prophet(saw) has approved of its content.

N.B

If the discharge of a womean in a state of menstruation or postnatal bleeding stops before sunset, it is obligatory for her to perform both the dhuhur and the 'asr prayers of the same day, and if the discharge stops before fajr , it is obligatory for her to perform both the maghrib and the isha prays of the same night. This is because the time of prayer for the latter is a permisible time of prayer for the latter is a permissivle time of prayer for the former in case of a legal excuse. Shaykhl-islam ibn taymiyah (ra) said

" so, the majority of scholars, such as malik, ash-shafi , and ahmad view that if a menstruating womans discharge stops at the end of daytime, it is obligatory for her to combine performing both dhuhur and asr prayers of the same day, and if the discharge stops at the end of the night , it is obligatory for her to combine performing both the maghrib and isha prayers of the same night. This is because there is a legal common specified time for every two successive prayers to be combined due to a legal excuse. to clarify, if a womans discharge stops at the end of the day , it is obligatory for her to perform the dhuhur prayer before the asr prayer for it is still a permissible time to perform the dhuhur prayer , i.e she is still at the specified period of the dhuhur prayer. Likewise, if that was at the end of the night , it is obligatory for her to perform the maghrib and the isha prayers, as she is still at the specified time of maghrib prayer. This ruling was nararated on the authority of Abdur-Rahman, Abu Hurayrah and ibn Abbas 6

If a woman starts discharging before she can perform an obligatory prayer at its specific time, the preponderant opinion is that she is not required to make up for such a prayer after her discharge stops. In this respect, Shaykhul-islam ibn taymiah (ra) said

"The opinion of the hanafi and maliki schools is the most cogent, as they maintain that a woman is not required to make up for such a missed prayer after her discharge stops. this is because making up for such a prayer necessitates a new legal command, and there is none in this case. Her delay of prayer is based on a legal excuse, so she is not to blame, as the delay is not of of neligence. If a muslim oversleeps or forgets to perform a prayer at its due time, though it is not out of negligence, the time of prayer starts for him when he gets up or remembers, and thus his prayer is not considered a way of making up for a missed one ."7

---------------------------------
1 Bukhari (331) [1/84] and muslim (751) [2/251]

2 Bukhari (304) [1/526]

3 Bukhari (321) [1/546] and muslim (761) [2/251]

4 muslim (692) [2/202], Ahmad (12339) [2/251] +more

5 Bukhari (326) [1/552], An-nasai (366) [1/204]

6 ibn Taymiahs majmu ul-fatawa [22/76]

7 ibn Taymiahs majmu ul-fatawa [23/335]

Part 2 coming soon bi ithnillah

Umm Ahmed
11th August 2006, 06:45 AM
Subhaan Allaah was thinking last night , I pray Abu Zubair gets on to Haid matters and here is your post . Jazak Allaah Khayran .

" so, the majority of scholars, such as malik, ash-shafi , and ahmad view that if a menstruating womans discharge stops at the end of daytime, it is obligatory for her to combine performing both dhuhur and asr prayers of the same day, and if the discharge stops at the end of the night , it is obligatory for her to combine performing both the maghrib and isha prayers of the same night. This is because there is a legal common specified time for every two successive prayers to be combined due to a legal excuse. to clarify, if a womans discharge stops at the end of the day , it is obligatory for her to perform the dhuhur prayer before the asr prayer for it is still a permissible time to perform the dhuhur prayer , i.e she is still at the specified period of the dhuhur prayer. Likewise, if that was at the end of the night , it is obligatory for her to perform the maghrib and the isha prayers, as she is still at the specified time of maghrib prayer. This ruling was nararated on the authority of Abdur-Rahman, Abu Hurayrah and ibn Abbas 6


SubhaanAllaah I never knew this :( any other daleel brother supporting this ?

juwairiyah
11th August 2006, 02:43 PM
Assalamo'alaykum Warahmatullah Wabarakatuh

Allahu Alam but is this strong opinion. I always read in fataw that if a woman became taahir at any time then she shd perform the salah of that waqt and not that if she became taahir at asr,she shd perform both dhuhr or asr as dhuhr has passed and she was not taahir at that time.

Abu Faaris As-Sumalee
11th August 2006, 08:58 PM
Question: Last week, I had my period after the dhuhur prayer had come in but before I had gotten around to praying it. Do I have to make up that prayer? Someone told me that I will have to make up the `Asr prayer as well. Is this true? If it is, does the same thing apply to Maghrib and `Îshâ’?

Answered by Sheikh `Abd al-Rahmân al-`Ajlân, lecturer at the Grand Mosque in Mecca

If the time of the dhuhr has already come in and a woman gets her period before she has had a chance to pray it, then she must make up her dhuhr prayer after her period is over.

Some scholars also say that she has to make up her `Asr prayer as well, since dhuhr and `Asr can be offered together for people who have an excuse, such as travelers.

Likewise if a woman’s menstrual period ends during the time of `Asr, she should pray her dhuhur prayer along with her `Asr prayer, since the two prayers can be offered together during the time of `Asr for people who have an excuse.

The same can be said for the Maghrib and `Îshâ’ prayers. Hence, if the time of Maghrib has already come in and the woman gets her period before she has had a chance to pray it, then she must make up both her Maghrib and `Ishâ’ prayers after her period is over. Likewise, if a woman’s menstrual period ends before the time of Fajr, she should pray her Maghrib prayer along with her `Ishâ’ prayer, since these two prayers can be offered together.

And Allah knows best.


I hope this is enough clarification. I will try to get some Quran and sunnah evedences in the mean while.

juwairiyah
13th August 2006, 04:23 AM
Assalamo'alaykum Warahmatullah Wabarakatuh

Allahu Alam, Salah is enjoined on the believers at fixed hours

http://www.islam-qa.com/index.php?ref=26336&ln=eng&txt=taahir

Umm Ahmed
13th August 2006, 07:41 AM
Assalamo'alaykum Warahmatullah Wabarakatuh

Allahu Alam, Salah is enjoined on the believers at fixed hours

http://www.islam-qa.com/index.php?ref=26336&ln=eng&txt=taahir


Wa alaykum as salaam

That fatwa speaks about what she has missed, although I have heard other scholars say she had the time to pray for it so its a debt and Allaah has all the knowledge , which is different to what the brother is saying. InshaaAllaah he can bring us clarity.

juwairiyah
13th August 2006, 01:07 PM
Assalamo'alaykum Warahmatullah Wabarakatuh

It says about both sis if she didnt pray dhuhr and her periods started after dhuhr then she has to offer dhuhr doesnt say she has to offer asr too.Likewise,if she becomes taahir (pure – i.e., her period ends) and there is still enough time left to do one or more rak'ahs, then she should pray the prayer during the time of which her period ended.So if periods ended at asr she ha sto offer asr only as she was not taahir at dhuhr.Allah Knows best

Abu Faaris As-Sumalee
13th August 2006, 01:50 PM
Please refer to Umm-Ahmad's qoute on post #2. Ibn Taymiah states ijma and also provides a consice explanation.

Umm Ahmed
13th August 2006, 02:38 PM
Assalamo'alaykum Warahmatullah Wabarakatuh

It says about both sis if she didnt pray dhuhr and her periods started after dhuhr then she has to offer dhuhr doesnt say she has to offer asr too.Likewise,if she becomes taahir (pure – i.e., her period ends) and there is still enough time left to do one or more rak'ahs, then she should pray the prayer during the time of which her period ended.So if periods ended at asr she ha sto offer asr only as she was not taahir at dhuhr.Allah Knows best


Wa alaykum us salaam Uktee I got this from Islam Today seems there is some iktilaf on this .

Question: What prayers must a woman make up if her bleeding comes to an end at night before dawn or in the late afternoon before sunset?

Answered by Sheikh `Abd al-`Azîz b. Bâz

According to the majority of scholars, if the woman’s menstruation ends before sunset, she should pray Zuhr and `Asr. If her menstruation ends before Fajr, she should pray Maghrib and `Ishâ’.

The reason for this is that the time for `Asr is the time for Zuhr for people who have an excuse, like people who are traveling. Likewise, the time of `Ishâ’ is also a time to perform Maghrib for people who have an excuse. The woman’s menstruation is an excuse for her not to pray, so if that excuse ends during the time of `Ishâ’, she must still pray Maghrib, and if that excuse ends during the time of `Asr, she must still pray Zuhr.

juwairiyah
14th August 2006, 12:14 PM
Assalamo'alaykum Warahmatullah Wabarakatuh

The reason for this is that the time for `Asr is the time for Zuhr for people who have an excuse, like people who are traveling. Likewise, the time of `Ishâ’ is also a time to perform Maghrib for people who have an excuse. The woman’s menstruation is an excuse for her not to pray, so if that excuse ends during the time of `Ishâ’, she must still pray Maghrib, and if that excuse ends during the time of `Asr, she must still pray Zuhr.

sis Allah made asaan for the person who is travelling to do qasr.A mensruating woman is diff from atraveller.She has to resume her salah only when she becomes taahir and offer the salah of that time as salah is enjoined upon a believer at fixed hours.Sis can a woman offer dhuhr and asr together if she fears her menses might start at asr.Answer is "no".She is not atravellor. if she menstruates at dhuhr but she did not offer dhuhr then she has to offer qadha of that waqt as it was obligatory upon her when dhuhr began but she is not to offer asr as asr was nt obligatory on her.Likewise,if she becomes taahir at asr then she has to offer asr only as at dhuhr she was not taahir and ALlah forbade a menstruating woman from making up salaah that she missed as a result of menses Allah Knows best : )

Umm Ahmed
14th August 2006, 04:26 PM
As salaamu alaykum Ukhtee thats a fatwa from sheik bin Baz , sadly it does not go into detail . Do you or anyone have the book "legal verdicts for women" I saw it in a bookshop but thought will get it next time , perhaps something is in there.