Riddle on Lineage

[Ibn Adam]

If you know the answer because you've heard it before please don't post it. But if you're genuinely guessing you're most welcome to try.

A man's daughter is his mother. How is this possible?

[Abu Maryam PK]

Please clarify whether this is islamically possible, or soething related to incest

[Abuz Zubair]

Abu Bakr's daughter, 'Aisha, is the mother of the believers, including Abu Bakr? just a guess.

[Abuz Zubair]

Please clarify whether this is islamically possible, or soething related to incest
What's incest got to do with this?!

[Abu Maryam PK]

What's incest got to do with this?!
i was thinking on the lines of Joseph 'Sep' Fritzl

[Abuz Zubair]

i was thinking on the lines of Joseph 'Sep' Fritzl
Yes, but it clearly says, the man's daughter is his mother. What's it gotta do with incest at all?

[Abu Maryam PK]

Yes, but it clearly says, the man's daughter is his mother. What's it gotta do with incest at all?
umm nothing..stupid of me...

[Umm Ahmed]

A man's daughter is his mother. How is this possible?

The fathers mother was still alive and she breastfed her grandchild so his daughter became his foster mother?

[Um Abdullah M.]

Fatimah radiyallahu anha
she was called "Ummu abiha" (mother of her father)
is that the answer?

[Abuz Zubair]

The fathers mother was still alive and she breastfed her grandchild so his daughter became his foster mother?
She would become her sister, in that case, wouldn't she?

[Umm Ahmed]

oh yes your right.
His grandmother fed her ? that could happen if each person had their first child when they are in their teens ? or is that too far fetched.


Fatimah radiyallahu anha
she was called "Ummu abiha" (mother of her father)
is that the answer?

Is that a hadith sister ? why was she called that ?

[Ibn Adam]

Abu Bakr's daughter, 'Aisha, is the mother of the believers, including Abu Bakr? just a guess.

Yes, masha' Allah, that's the right answer. Or, you could have said 'Umar and Hafsa too.

[Ibn Adam]

Please clarify whether this is islamically possible, or soething related to incest
What's incest got to do with this?!
umm nothing..stupid of me...
The Shallal Pastries are probably getting to you bro.

[Abu Maryam PK]

The Shallal Pastries are probably getting to you bro.
hmmm...i seem to recognize u now. See u tuesday then...
i always suspected u post here [smile]

[Ibn Adam]

Tuesday, it is then.