PDA

View Full Version : Is this Hadith Saheeh?


al-Khurasaanie
29th September 2006, 03:37 PM
As-Salaam Alaykom Warahmatolah Wabarakhatoh,

"On the authority of Zaid bin Aslam Al-Adawi (RA) from his father (RA),the Messenger of Allaah,the Most High,said:Jihaad will remain sweet and green as long as rain continues to drop from the sky,yet,there will come upon the people a time when their scholars will say:'This is not the time for Jihaad.'So whoever witnesses this time then let him know that this is the best time for Jihaad." The Companions asked: "O Messenger of Allaah,will anyone really say that?" He (pbuh) replied: "Yes,he upon whom is the curse of Allaah,His Angels and all of mankind." [Ibn Asakir transmitted it.(Mashari-ul-Ashwaaq by Ibn Nuhaas, Vol 1,P.110)

I tried to find it back in the Mashari-ul-Ashwaaq of the online version but i din't find it, does someone knows something about this Hadith?

Wasalaam Alaykom,
'Abdoer-Rahmaan al-Khurasaanie.

Abuz Zubair
30th September 2006, 12:34 PM
http://www.ahlalhdeeth.com/vb/showthread.php?threadid=4793

Hadeeth is mursal

Suhaib Jobst
30th September 2006, 01:06 PM
Hadeeth is mursal

Are there any ahadeeth which support this narration? Because no doubt its meaning is correct.

al-Khurasaanie
30th September 2006, 01:41 PM
http://www.ahlalhdeeth.com/vb/showthread.php?threadid=4793

Hadeeth is mursal

Barak Allahu Feek Agy...

Do you also know if this hadeeth is mentiond in other hadeeth books apart from Ibn Asakir? and thougth, there are scholars who see mursal hadiths as acceptable, so is the chain Ok?

Your reward is with Allah ta'ala,

Wasalaam.

Abu_Abdallah
30th September 2006, 03:22 PM
About the Mursal Hadith people differ: the most reliably opinion seem to be that it depends on the Mursal hadith itself. After reading the posts mentioned in the link of brother Abuz Zubair, the narration is surely weak - unless there are other chains of transmission?