Shaykh Suhaib's anger at Madkhali movement

[thefitrah]

I got this link from 'salafitalk' which effectively brings to light their own errors in dealing with muslims. this is an apparent evidence of Suhaib Hasan's disrespect towards the ulema wud u believe it! but is does the contrary for me, just displays the frustration and annoyance of the senior people of knowledge towards these young sectarian nutters:

http://www.salafitalk.net/st/uploads/SuhaibHasanAttacksScholarsMP3a.mp3



ive never heard Shaykh Suhaib so annoyed!

[ibn 'abd al-jabbaar]

as-salaamu 'alaikum

never heard the shaykh that angry before, may Allah preserve him.

[Madarijas-Salikeen]

salamu alaykum

arent ulama in favor of salafitalk.net? They have a thread qouting from ulama praising salafitalk.net

[thefitrah]

I have not personally come across the praise of salafitalk from the ulema. however they do have threads in which they quote certain scholars praising spubs (synonomous with salafitalk). this is not hard to believe, and if you look at the praise you will find that it is a general praise, a praise that can be applied to any muslim organistation who generally calls to returning to the quran and sunnah.

the various quotations of certain ulema do not deal with the specific problematic charachteristics of this organisation. e.g. slandering du'at, labelling sincere callers to Haq as deviants, disrespecting the ulema, making certain ijtihaads of some scholars obligatory on all muslims, isolating themselves from general muslim populous, etc

so praise from Ulema should not be taking as the sole standard of measurng the reliability of a particular organisation, as scholars are not constanly exposed to the non-praiseworthy attributes of many organisations.

[abu khattab]

Salama 3alikeum wa rahmatullahi wa barakaatuhu

Salafinet has been criticsed publicly by a saudi shiekh, whose words were twisted and later this websites owner was contacted by this sheikh and was told to fear Allah. The sheikh later gave a small talk against these people. The file is avalibale on internet. I heard it with my own ears but need to find the exact location as i forgot it. However, in mean time, stay away from these people, who are not afraid from twisting people's words to cause, either corruption or support thier "hizb"

Wa salama 3aliekum wa rahmatullahi wa barakaatuhu

[thefitrah]

there you go.

try and get that link akhi, should be good.

Ja Zakullah Khair

[abu hafs]

http://madeenah.com/article.cfm?id=1075