PDA

View Full Version : Hindu gets custody of children from Muslim wife


Umm
13th May 2007, 10:35 AM
May 3, 2007

KUALA LUMPUR -- A Malaysian Hindu man forcibly separated from his Muslim wife by Islamic authorities because they are of different religions was Thursday granted custody of their children in a milestone case.

The children will be raised as Hindus in central Selangor state despite having one Muslim parent - which lawyers said was unprecedented in mainly Muslim Malaysia.

Selangor Islamic authorities last month forcibly separated ethnic Indian P. Marimuthu from his ethnic Indian Muslim wife of 21 years, Raimah Bibi Noordin and six of their seven children.

During a high court hearing west of Kuala Lumpur, Raimah, 39, clad in traditional Malay floor-length attire with a Muslim headscarf, told the judge that she was voluntarily giving up custody of her children.

"I agree to hand over the custody of my children to my husband to be raised as Hindus," Raimah said, before she broke down in tears.

Under Malaysian law, a non-Muslim must convert to Islam in order to marry a Muslim, and children born to Muslims must be raised as followers of that religion.

Government legal advisor Zauyah Be Loth Khan said that Selangor's Islamic Affairs Department did not object to the children being raised as Hindus.

"She is still entitled to visiting rights at any time," Zauyah told reporters.

"It sets a new precedent," said Marimuthu's lawyer Karpal Singh, also a lawmaker with the opposition Democratic Action Party (DAP).

Marimuthu, 43, applied for custody of the children after they were placed with Raimah in an ethnic Malay Muslim village.

Islamic authorities said that they separated the couple after they recently found out that she was a Muslim.

"I have had discussions with my husband ... with regard to the predicament facing the both of us, and I hereby state that I was born a Muslim and I wish to continue professing the Islamic faith," Raimah said in an affidavit to the court.

Marimuthu has said that Raimah, an ethnic Indian, was adopted by an Indian Muslim family but was a practicing Hindu.

They were married 21 years ago according to Hindu rites and raised their seven children, aged four to 14, as Hindus, he said.:eek:

Raimah's case comes amid growing sensitivities over the rights of non-Muslims in Malaysia.

Rights groups have condemned the actions of the Islamic authorities, saying that freedom of religious practice is guaranteed in Malaysia's constitution.

"Relationships should not be broken up by religion, which is supposed to foster family love and unity," said DAP parliamentary opposition leader Lim Kit Siang.

Middle East Times (http://www.metimes.com/storyview.php?StoryID=20070503-060203-5633r)

morbius
13th May 2007, 02:20 PM
It is really sad to see state separate two people who live together in happy marriage. Their religion is their choice.

Umm Ahmed
13th May 2007, 03:00 PM
What this shows is that what Allaah legislated in the Quran and Sunnah is for our own good , she is a muslimah but as a woman she followed her husbands rules and allowed her children to become Hindus.

This is a perfect example of why a muslim woman should only marry a muslim man.

Abd al-Haqq Marshall
13th May 2007, 07:20 PM
What kind of a "Muslimah" would marry a Hindu idol-worshipper!?

Yasir
13th May 2007, 09:44 PM
What kind of a "Muslimah" would marry a Hindu idol-worshipper!?One that didn't know it was impermissible?

gag order
13th May 2007, 09:59 PM
Rights groups have condemned the actions of the Islamic authorities, saying that freedom of religious practice is guaranteed in Malaysia's constitution.

and thats why they seperated them, its freedom to implement religious practice as guaranteed in the constitution..

They were married 21 years ago according to Hindu rites and raised their seven children, aged four to 14, as Hindus, he said

kufr and shirk and zina, how convenient!

Abd al-Haqq Marshall
13th May 2007, 10:55 PM
One that didn't know it was impermissible?

If she didn't know it was haraam to marry an idol-worshipper, what DID she know about Islam?

Abu_Abdillah2000
14th May 2007, 11:45 AM
Marimuthu has said that Raimah, an ethnic Indian, was adopted by an Indian Muslim family but was a practicing Hindu.

Wait a minute, he says his wife Raimah was a "practicing Hindu", but she says she's a Muslimah? What's going on then?

Anyway, this article demonstrates the whole problem of "modernist Muslims" and those who don't even care a less about following their religion and obeying Allah. They tend to end up getting caught in disastrous and permanent predicaments.