Qardawi speaks again... talk about deviant!

[salafi brother]

The words of Sheikh Yusuf Al-Qardaawee:

In the name of Allaah, the most merciful, and the victory is for the ones who have Taqwaa (fear for Allaah),and the best prayers and peace be upon the one who Allaah sent as a mercy for all mankind, and a argument to all the people, our Sayyid, and our Imaam (leader), and our role model, and our beloved, and our teacher Muhammad may the peace be upon him and his family, friends, and whoever called with his call and is guided with his Sunnah until the last day.

As to what follows:
Is has been our custom in this program to give information about the Ulemaa' (Scholars) from the Muslims when they leave from this Dunyaa (the current life) to the Daar al-Aakhirah (the last life), but now we will not follow this custom we will talk about a scholar but not from the scholars of Islaam, rather he is from the scholars of Christianity, who is the most Holy [of Christianity] and he is The Pope John Paul II, the pope of the Vatican and the Catholic Church and the most esteemed man in the Christian Religion.
He has passed away yesterday (Apr 2nd, 2005) and the world has been devastated by the news this passing away, and it is our right, rather it is from our requirement to express our consolation to the Christian nation and to the [Christian] priests in the Vatican and in other than the Vatican in [all] the world and some of them are our [Qardaawee's] friends, we saw them in more than [one] conference and more than [one] discussion, and more than [one] dialogue, we present to those [Christians] our Consolation in the death of this most esteemed man that the Christians chose most of the time as a free choice, we the Muslims dream to be able to chose their biggest [leading] Shaykh, our their biggest leader (Imaam) with free choice, and without the appointment of a Country from the countries or a Government from the governments, we present our Condolences for this Pope who had positions they are mentioned and he is thanked, maybe some of the Muslims say that he hasn’t apologized about the Christian wars and the tragedies that happened for the Muslims as [he has] apologized to the Jews and some of them take on him some things, but the positions of the main man and his sincerity in preaching his religion and his enthusiasm despite his old age, and his age became old, he has traveled all of the world and visited Countries and from them the countries of the Muslims themselves, so he was sincere in his religion and enthusiastic amongst the most enthusiastic in the spreading of his call (Christianity) and the faith in his message and he had political positions meaning that they are recorded in his good deeds [also] for example his position against the wars in general.

So he was a man of peace and a caller to peace and he took positions against the war against Iraq, and he also took positions against construction of the separation wall in the Palestinian land, and he condemned the Jews in that, and he has positions for example [what we have mentioned] it is mentioned and he is praised.. we cant except ask Allaah to have mercy upon him and reward him for what he has done of good for humanity and what he has done of righteous work and good tracks and we give our Condolences to the Christians all over the world and our friends in Rome and our friends in The Society of St. Tedio in Rome and we ask Allaah to compensate the Christian nation where good is. [END]

comments?......

[Abu_Abdillah2000]

comments?......

No comment...

[salafi brother]

Salaamu `Alaykum

Shaykh Abu Ishaaq al-Huwaynee (Hafidhahullaah) refuted it mashallaah, its funny at the beginning he says, "He (Qaradaawee) said some words (about the pope) that you could say about Shaykhs Albaanee and Ibn Baaz, May Allaah have mercy on them both."

here is the link, listen: http://www.al-heweny.com/media3/details.php?linkid=553

Qardaawee said this on al-Jazeerah! Inshallaah im gonna bring more wierd fatwas of qardaawee

[Brother_Mujahid]

Why? What is the point? I don't think al-Qaradawi has many fans on this forum so you'd just be wasting your time.

[JayshAllah]

Although Shaykh Qaradawi has passed some strange fatwas in the past, should we not address him with respect due to a scholar?

[knowrass]

jazaak Allaah for shaykh al-huwayni's refutation.

[salafi brother]

Although Shaykh Qaradawi has passed some strange fatwas in the past, should we not address him with respect due to a scholar?

Salaamu Alaykum

The scholars said, (as Yahya Ibraheem mentioned in "Knowledge is Cure" produced by Huda RP [hudarp.com]) that the scholar is not the one who knows alot, rather he is the one who acts upon his knowledge. And Yahya gives and example, the Azhar shcolars, one of them could sit down and write the whole saheeh al-bukhari. but what? they dont act upon it, i.e. thowbs dragging 3 feet behind them, clean shaven etc. Yahya also mentioned that a old woman who knows little about islaam but acts upon it is more fit to the title of scholar than some of the Azhar scholars. Dont get me wrong, some of the Azhar scholars are really, really good, like i think Ahmad Shaakir was from Azhar, and look at him mashallaah

[salafi brother]

Why? What is the point? I don't think al-Qaradawi has many fans on this forum so you'd just be wasting your time.

Salaamu `Alaykum

Yeah but some of the brothers or sisters on here may want to show some of his muqallids, just for reference. Remember waht Ibn Taymiyyah said?
http://forums.islamicawakening.com/showthread.php?t=5159

[JayshAllah]

Salaamu Alaykum

The scholars said, (as Yahya Ibraheem mentioned in "Knowledge is Cure" produced by Huda RP [hudarp.com]) that the scholar is not the one who knows alot, rather he is the one who acts upon his knowledge. And Yahya gives and example, the Azhar shcolars, one of them could sit down and write the whole saheeh al-bukhari. but what? they dont act upon it, i.e. thowbs dragging 3 feet behind them, clean shaven etc. Yahya also mentioned that a old woman who knows little about islaam but acts upon it is more fit to the title of scholar than some of the Azhar scholars. Dont get me wrong, some of the Azhar scholars are really, really good, like i think Ahmad Shaakir was from Azhar, and look at him mashallaah

I think it's this harshness that is hard for me to deal with...sigh, I guess I'll get used to it and maybe become just as harsh one day, lol...

[Yasir]

wa'alaikum as-salaam wa rahmatullah,

Does Yahya Ibrahim then consider Sh. al-Qardawi to not be a scholar?
He may have his fair share of mistakes, but have you ever read his work, such as his book on Zakah?

[salafi brother]

Salaamu `Alaykum

I dont know if Yahya Ibraheem considres Qardaawee to be a scholar, in that lecture he wasent pointing to any specifc figures.
I havent read any of his books, I know that his book on Halaal and Haraam has many mistakes, and Shaykh Albani made Tahqeeq on it, so it must've had mistakes. And his fair share of mistakes is so much that it would take month to collect them all, Shaykh Albani talked about him and said that he has "`Aqeedatun-Azhariyyah".

[Brother_Mujahid]

I'm no fan of Shaykh Yusuf al-Qaradawi, I obviously have many problems with certain statements he has made in the past. That being said, I notice many brothers waste some much time "refuting" or "exposing" al-Qaradawi, often on things which he has already been addressed with by actual scholars. People need to be just when dealing with other Muslims, especially scholars, and not go digging around for their faults. Thus I ask Allah to guide Shaykh al-Qaradawi away from any mistakes which he has fallen into and to reward him for the benefical works he has preformed for the 'ummah.

[Skillganon]

True.

Their is also lot of damage he is doing and you cannot pass everything as mistake.

To me his to pro-western for me. He tries to water down and Justify certain things that goes against common sense.

May allah(swt) guide him.

[salafi brother]

I'm no fan of Shaykh Yusuf al-Qaradawi, I obviously have many problems with certain statements he has made in the past. That being said, I notice many brothers waste some much time "refuting" or "exposing" al-Qaradawi, often on things which he has already been addressed with by actual scholars. People need to be just when dealing with other Muslims, especially scholars, and not go digging around for their faults. Thus I ask Allah to guide Shaykh al-Qaradawi away from any mistakes which he has fallen into and to reward him for the benefical works he has preformed for the 'ummah.

Salaamu `Alaykum

Bro what ever happend to Amr Bil Ma`roof wan Nahee `an al-Munkar?? Im not digging anywhere for anyones mistakes, he puts this on al-jazeerah and his own website, its not like he is trying to conceal it. Im merely showing you what he says, espesially on a site like this that gets thousands (maybe even tens of thousands) of visits a day, its better to show people what he says so that he can be avoided. This guy Qardawee made Kufr statements such as, "Had Allaah come down from the heavens he wouldent have won that election." he compares allaah to a jew! that jew that won the isreali vice-presidential elections, he won by 99% of the votes, and Qardaawee compares him to Allaah.

Ibn Uthaymeen made takfeer on this man, and he said unless he makes a clear recantation and repentance he is a Kaafir. If you listen to Shaykh Abu Ishaaq's refutation, he says the statement "Man Laa Yukaffir al-Kaafir fa Huwa Kaafir".

[JayshAllah]

To me his to pro-western for me. He tries to water down and Justify certain things that goes against common sense.

I don't think so at all. He is not pro-western in the sense that he is a puppet of the West. He is hated by the West. Yes, his Dawah approach is designed for the West, but that is different than being a puppet of the West, like the Saudi regime is a puppet of the West.

I think Shaykh Qaradawi is a sincere person who has dedicated his life to Islam. He may have mistakes, not denying that. I think we should respect scholars, that is all. I think if you were fair and just--instead of being hizbi--you would come to the ruling that Shaykh Qaradawi is a sincere person who is not a puppet of the West. Furthermore, he has done many good things for Islam.

[justabro]

Salaamu Alaykum

The scholars said, (as Yahya Ibraheem mentioned in "Knowledge is Cure" produced by Huda RP [hudarp.com]) that the scholar is not the one who knows alot, rather he is the one who acts upon his knowledge. And Yahya gives and example, the Azhar shcolars, one of them could sit down and write the whole saheeh al-bukhari. but what? they dont act upon it, i.e. thowbs dragging 3 feet behind them, clean shaven etc. Yahya also mentioned that a old woman who knows little about islaam but acts upon it is more fit to the title of scholar than some of the Azhar scholars. Dont get me wrong, some of the Azhar scholars are really, really good, like i think Ahmad Shaakir was from Azhar, and look at him mashallaah

Wa alaykum assalam

no disrespect brother, and I certainly dont mean any disrespect for Sh. Ahmad Shakir, but he was also clean shaven as Abuz-Zubair has mentioned on other threads. I don't approve of it, but, I still respect him as a great scholar.

[salafi brother]

Wa alaykum assalam

no disrespect brother, and I certainly dont mean any disrespect for Sh. Ahmad Shakir, but he was also clean shaven as Abuz-Zubair has mentioned on other threads. I don't approve of it, but, I still respect him as a great scholar.

Salaamu `Alaykum

Yeah I knew that, I seen the pic, but compared to other Azhar Scholars, he was pretty much better than the others, eventhough he had no beard.

[salafi brother]

I don't think so at all. He is not pro-western in the sense that he is a puppet of the West. He is hated by the West. Yes, his Dawah approach is designed for the West, but that is different than being a puppet of the West, like the Saudi regime is a puppet of the West.

I think Shaykh Qaradawi is a sincere person who has dedicated his life to Islam. He may have mistakes, not denying that. I think we should respect scholars, that is all. I think if you were fair and just--instead of being hizbi--you would come to the ruling that Shaykh Qaradawi is a sincere person who is not a puppet of the West. Furthermore, he has done many good things for Islam.

Salaamu `Alaykum

Bro, according to Ibn Abdul-Wahhaab's book, Nawaaqidh al-Islaam, point three, he falls under that category, im not making takfeer of him, because im noone to do so. I dont know whats your problem calling people Hizbee, if you were fair and just, you would not be following him to such an extent that you dont realize that he has made huge mistakes, or just dont want to admit it.

This guy is not a scholar, he does not act upon his knowledge, he has knowledge no doubt, he's an older brother over 70 yrs old. You need to realize the truth, that according to Ibn Uthaymeen, unless this guy makes public Tawbah from statements such as, "Had Allaah come down he wouldent have won that ellection", and "He was a agreat caller to peace and a strong supporter of his religion", according to Ibn Uthaymeen, he is an apostate.

[Skillganon]

I agree somewhat Salafi Brother here.

Some of the strange statement you cannot defend or cannot be passed of mistakes, as their is to many and they don't sound like an honest mistake.

Unless he's gone grazy otherwise he needs to make tawbah and rectify some of the damage he is doing.

[salafi brother]

I agree somewhat Salafi Brother here.



Salaamu `Alaykum

Thats better than nothing, people on here dont like me

[Skillganon]

Salaamu `Alaykum

Thats better than nothing, people on here dont like me

Assalamu alaikum wr wb rbo

I don't it is the case tha non here likes you.

I don't know what makes you say that.

If it because of some comments coming in response to yours, be it disagreement or correction. You should not take that as somekind of deslike.
When it comes to correction in the deen , than stand on your feet but stand corrected.

We are all here to learn, and no one can deslike you for that.

[salafi brother]

Assalamu alaikum wr wb rbo

I don't it is the case tha non here likes you.

I don't know what makes you say that.

If it because of some comments coming in response to yours, be it disagreement or correction. You should not take that as somekind of deslike.
When it comes to correction in the deen , than stand on your feet but stand corrected.

We are all here to learn, and no one can deslike you for that.

Salaamu `Alaykum

Im not complaining, it makes me feel like a Ghareeb, haha, its some of the 'comments' made by some of the brothers on here that gave me that impression that they dont like me because they are calling me a "Salafi=Talafi Brother=Retard"

[Skillganon]

Salaamu `Alaykum

Im not complaining, it makes me feel like a Ghareeb, haha, its some of the 'comments' made by some of the brothers on here that gave me that impression that they dont like me because they are calling me a "Salafi=Talafi Brother=Retard"

Well this comment is out of order. It does not take a genious to know that.
Sometime debate or disagreement gets heated and this words can easily fly out.
So don't worry about it.

[salafi brother]

Salaamu `Alaykum

Well anyway back to the topic, Qardawi said,

- وأستمع أحياناً إلى أم كلثوم (!!) في "نهج البردة"، أو "سلوا قلبي غداة سلا وتابا".

and I listen sometimes to Umm Kalthoom (!!) in, "Nahj al-Bardah" or, "Saloo Qalbee Ghadaa Salaa wa Taabaa" (a couple of Um Kalthoom's songs i guess)

I think this Umm Kalthoom is eygptian too

here's the reference:
جريدة الراية القطرية. الجمعة 1419 هـ الموافق لـ 11 سبتمبر 1998. (العدد: 9 /حوارات/ الوجه الآخر لفضيلة الشيخ يوسف القرضاوي. وكذا في العدد الذي سبقه. ص: 26 ربيع الثاني . العدد (11722).

[salafi brother]

OH here's the reference for the Above post:

جريدة الراية القطرية. الجمعة 1419 هـ الموافق لـ 11 سبتمبر 1998. (العدد: 9 /حوارات/ الوجه الآخر لفضيلة الشيخ يوسف القرضاوي. وكذا في العدد الذي سبقه. ص: 26 ربيع الثاني . العدد (11722).

[salafi brother]

- وأستمع بحب (!!) وأتأثر بشدة (!!) بصوت فايزة أحمد (!!) خاصة وهي تغني الأغنيات الخاصة بالأسرة: "ست الحبايب"، و "يا حبيبي يا خويا" !، و "يا بو عيالي"، و "بيت العز يا بيتنا على بابك عنبتنا".

And I listen with love (!!) and I am highly effected (!!) from the voice of Faai'zah Ahmah (!!), especially when she is singing the specifically the songs about the Usrah (Family), and "Satt al-Habaayib", and, "Yaa Habibi Yaa Khooyaa", and Yaa Bu `Aalee", and "Bayt al-`Izz Yaa Baytinaa `Alaa Baabika`Anbatanaa"

This is from the same source of the above one, in that article by him he announced all of his deviant beleifs!

جريدة الراية القطرية. الجمعة 1419 هـ الموافق لـ 11 سبتمبر 1998. (العدد: 9 /حوارات/ الوجه الآخر لفضيلة الشيخ يوسف القرضاوي. وكذا في العدد الذي سبقه. ص: 26 ربيع الثاني . العدد (11722).

[Abu_Abdillah2000]

The Messenger of Allah, sallallahu 'alayhi wa-sallam, spoke of a time in which groups of people would appear in the Ummah who would treat as lawful adultery, silk, intoxicants and musical instruments. He also said that some of those people will be punished by being destroyed by showers of stones, being swallowed up by the earth, and being changed into pigs and monkeys!

Look at how many Muslims wear silk today (especially silk ties etc.), and all of the "tricks" and "loopholes" some of the corrupt 'ulama find to excuse them.

Regarding zina, then just look at the recent request by some shi'i women in Iraq asking Muqtada as-Sadr for his fatwa on "group mut'ah sessions" with the members of "Jaysh al-Mahdi", and how he encouraged them to do it and said that its reward it greater than that of ordinary mut'ah!

There are also some pretty bizarre fatwas out there in some countries about alcoholic drinks!

But the most widespread of these things is of course music. Here, al-Qaradhawi did not simply stop at legalising music, he went even further and allows people to follow his own example in listening to low-life, cheap, uncovered woman singers!

May Allah not destroy us for what the fools among us have done!

[salafi brother]

Salaamu `Alaykum

Here is the best (by best i mean worst) one yet:

من المعلوم أن فضيلة الشيخ القرضاوي يرى جواز السباحة في مسبح مختلط مع نساء يسبحن في مايوهات، بشرط أن يحاول غض البصر عن النساء. وهذه الفتوى قديمة عنه. ولكن باعتبار أنه حاول مرة إيهام الناس بأنه لم يصدر مثل هذه الفتوى

"It is known that "Fadilat Ash-Shaykh" al-Qardaawee sees that it is permissible to swim in a public pool with even women swimming, with the rule that he tries to not look at the women(!!!!). And this is one of his older Fatwaas. But take with considreation that he tried to delude the people into thinking that he did not release a Fatwaa like this."

[زعم ذلك في لقاء مفتوح في موقعه بتاريخ هـ الموافق 17/12/2000م، في قناة الجزيرة.]

[salafi brother]

Salaamu `Alaykum
Heres one about the voice of the Woman

- وهذه أغنيات لطيفة جداً! فأنا لا أرى أن صوت المرأة عورة في ذاته. لكنه عورة حينما يراد به الإثارة والتمييع والتكسر، ويهدف إلى الإغراء.

"And these sons and very good! (Meaning the aforementioned ones with Umm Kalthoom and the other lady) I dont see that the voice of the woman is `Awrah alone. But it is `Awrah when it leads to sensual [acts], and a break-down, and it leads to seduction."

المرجع: جريدة الراية القطرية. الجمعة 1419 هـ الموافق لـ 11 سبتمبر 1998. (العدد: 9 /حوارات/ الوجه الآخر لفضيلة الشيخ يوسف القرضاوي. وكذا في العدد الذي سبقه. ص: 26 ربيع الثاني . العدد (11722).

[stani]

What to say about a human being who possibly misled more other humans than any of his contemporaries? A taghut who promoted the worst sin, declared what is lawful as unlawful and what is unlawful as lawful, while people followed him? Should one weep for him? Indeed.
Muslims ought to recognize the enormity of the crime of disbelief and attributing a son to Allah the Most High.

The Qur'an says,

"And they say, ‘The Most Merciful has taken a son.’ You have done an atrocious thing. The heavens almost rupture therefrom and the earth splits open and the mountains collapse in devastation. That they attribute to the Most Merciful a son. And it is not appropriate for the Most Merciful that He should take a son. There is no one in the heavens and earth but that he comes to the Most Merciful as a servant." [Maryam: 88-93]


Their deeds are futile, while they were thinking otherwise:

"Say: ‘Shall we not inform regarding the greatest losers concerning their deeds? They are those whose efforts are wasted in the worldly life, whilst thinking that they were performing the best of actions." [al-Kahf: 103-4]



“Those who disbelieved - their deeds are like a mirage on a plain, in which a thirsty person thinks there is water; when he approaches it he finds nothing but he finds Allah before him and He repays him his account in full, as Allah is swift in taking account.” [al-Noor: 39]


The worthlesness of their hard labor is also explained in the following passage from Tafsir Ibn Kathir (of Soorah al-Ghashiyah):

(Some faces that Day will be Khashi`ah) meaning, humiliated. This was said by Qatadah. Ibn `Abbas said, "They will be humble but this action will be of no benefit to them.'' Then Allah says,

(Laboring, weary) meaning, they did many deeds and became weary in their performance, yet they will be cast into a blazing Fire on the Day of Judgement. Al-Hafiz Abu Bakr Al-Burqani narrated from Abu `Imran Al-Jawni that he said, " `Umar bin Al-Khattab passed by the monastery of a monk and he said: `O monk!' Then the monk came out, and `Umar looked at him and began to weep. Then it was said to him: `O Commander of the faithful! Why are you weeping' He replied: `I remembered the statement of Allah, the Mighty and Majestic, in His Book,

(Laboring, weary. They will enter into Fire, Hamiyah.) So that is what has made me cry. ''' Al-Bukhari recorded that Ibn `Abbas said,

(Laboring, weary) "The Christians.'' It is narrated that `Ikrimah and As-Suddi both said, "Laboring in the worldly life with disobedience, and weariness in the Fire from torment and perdition.'' Ibn `Abbas, Al-Hasan, and Qatadah all said,

(They will enter into Fire, Hamiyah) meaning, hot with intense heat.


Extracted from “Tafsir In Kathir”, © Darussalam. Taken rom www.islaam.com


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------