hadith : How many gods do you worship ?

[Abou_Tourab]

salam alaikoum

I was reading the explanation of kashf shoubouhat by Muhammed ibn Ibrahim and i found this hadith :

The Prophet sallAllahou alaihi wa sallam asked Hussain "How many gods do you worship?" He said : "Seven, six of them on the earth and one over the heaven" So he asked him "In which of them do you place your aspiration and your awe?" He said : "The One over the heaven"."

Is it authentic ?

[Abuz Zubair]

ِAs far as I remember, yes it is.

[ali]

and what is it's diraya

[Abu Talhah]

salam alaikoum

I was reading the explanation of kashf shoubouhat by Muhammed ibn Ibrahim and i found this hadith :

The Prophet sallAllahou alaihi wa sallam asked Hussain "How many gods do you worship?" He said : "Seven, six of them on the earth and one over the heaven" So he asked him "In which of them do you place your aspiration and your awe?" He said : "The One over the heaven"."

Is it authentic ?

wa 'Alaaykum as-Salaam, can you tell me what part of the book it says that, so I can look it up in the Sharh im reading insha 'Allah

[aburasheed]

It's one of the hadiths that links rububiyyah and uluhiyyah, I believe in Saheeh Muslim: The Prophet - sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam - said to Husain (father of Imran), "How many [gods] do you worship?" He replied, "Six on earth and one in heaven." The Prophet then said, "Whom do you worship for your needs and when you are in fear?" He replied, "The one in heaven." The Prophet then said, "Leave the six [on earth] and worship [only] the one in heaven and I will teach you two prayers." He became a Muslim. And the Prophet - sallallahu `alayhi wa sallam - taught him [to pray], "O Allah inspire me with my guidance and preserve me from the evils of my soul."

[islamic@rebel]

^^^ I couldn't find it in Muslim akhi. Could you direct me.

The hadith is in Tirmidhi, kitabut tawhid of ibnu khuzaimah and adh-dhahabi with his own isnad in al-uluww.

1- as for the one in the sunan, albani weakened it. In the chain is shabeeb bin shaibah and he is weak in hadith. Abu dawud, an-nasa'i, abu zur'ah and ad-daraqutni said so.
also al-hasan did not hear from imran.

2- As for the ibnu khuzaimah's chain, it goes:-
imran bin khalid, from his father khalid bin Tulaiq, from Tulaiq's father Muhammad, from Muhammad's father Imran bin Husain who narrates the story.

Imran bin Khalid is weak, according to adh-dhahabi. Imam Ahmad said he was matruk. Abu Hatim said: Weak. And Ibnu Hibban forbade using him as proof.

Khalid is not strong, according to ad-daraqutni. And Ibnu Hibban mentions him in ath-thiqaat.

Regarding Tulaiq, Adh-dhahabi said: Tulaiq from Imran bin Husayn is munqati'. Ibnu Hibban mentions tulaiq in his thiqaat.

adh-dhahbi weakens the hadith base on the weakness of imran bin khalid alone.

[aburasheed]

^^^ I couldn't find it in Muslim akhi. Could you direct me.

The hadith is in Tirmidhi, kitabut tawhid of ibnu khuzaimah and adh-dhahabi with his own isnad in al-uluww.

1- as for the one in the sunan, albani weakened it. In the chain is shabeeb bin shaibah and he is weak in hadith. Abu dawud, an-nasa'i, abu zur'ah and ad-daraqutni said so.
also al-hasan did not hear from imran.

2- As for the ibnu khuzaimah's chain, it goes:-
imran bin khalid, from his father khalid bin Tulaiq, from Tulaiq's father Muhammad, from Muhammad's father Imran bin Husain who narrates the story.

Imran bin Khalid is weak, according to adh-dhahabi. Imam Ahmad said he was matruk. Abu Hatim said: Weak. And Ibnu Hibban forbade using him as proof.

Khalid is not strong, according to ad-daraqutni. And Ibnu Hibban mentions him in ath-thiqaat.

Regarding Tulaiq, Adh-dhahabi said: Tulaiq from Imran bin Husayn is munqati'. Ibnu Hibban mentions tulaiq in his thiqaat.

adh-dhahbi weakens the hadith base on the weakness of imran bin khalid alone.
Jazakallah Kheir, I searched in Muslim as well, but could not find it.

[islamic@rebel]

waiyyakum akhi thanks. I thought my ctrl-f functiion didnt work.

[IbnShaykh]

salam alaikoum

I was reading the explanation of kashf shoubouhat by Muhammed ibn Ibrahim and i found this hadith :

The Prophet sallAllahou alaihi wa sallam asked Hussain "How many gods do you worship?" He said : "Seven, six of them on the earth and one over the heaven" So he asked him "In which of them do you place your aspiration and your awe?" He said : "The One over the heaven"."

Is it authentic ?

Bismillah

Where is this book avalible? is it avalible online as a pdf?

[AbuHafsa]

Salaamu Alaykum WaRahmatullah,

Selected Readings from Kashf al-Shubuhaat are available at this link:
http://abdurrahman.org/tawheed/removalofdoubts1to11.pdf

For a Detailed / Critical Study of Shirk, refer to the “Explanation of Kashf al-Shubuhaat” by Shaykh Abu Ammar Yasir al-Qadhi – Published by al-Hidaayah, UK:

http://kitaabun.com/shopping3/product_info.php?products_id=1612

[IbnShaykh]

Salaamu Alaykum WaRahmatullah,

Selected Readings from Kashf al-Shubuhaat are available at this link:
http://abdurrahman.org/tawheed/removalofdoubts1to11.pdf

For a Detailed / Critical Study of Shirk, refer to the “Explanation of Kashf al-Shubuhaat” by Shaykh Abu Ammar Yasir al-Qadhi – Published by al-Hidaayah, UK:

http://kitaabun.com/shopping3/product_info.php?products_id=1612

Jzack Allahu Khair but I was specifically refering to the sharh by Shaykh Muhammad Ibn Ibrahim