AhluSunnah
19th June 2007, 07:19 PM
Salaamun Alaykum,
Can someone please enlight me about the authenticity of the below metioned hadeeth? I have heard that Ibn al-Qayyim and others have declared it as saheeh but i also have come to know that Al-Albaanee has declared it as Da3eef. Can we say that this hadeeth is weak for positive surety? And are there any other ahadeeth narrated with this wording in other hadeeth collections which would strengthen this narration?
Barak Allahu feekum.
Abu Dawud also published from Umm Salamah by way of Salih Abu'l-Khaleel from a companion of his from Umm Sal amah, that he said,
يكون اختلاف ثم موت خليفة يخرج رجل من قريش من
أهل المدينة إلى مكة فيأتيه ناس من اهل مكة فيخرجونه وهو
كاره فيبايعونه بين الركن والمقام إليه جيشا من أهل الشام
فإذا كانوا بالبيداء خسف بهم فإذا بلغ الناس ذلك أتاه أهل
الشام وعصائب من أهل العراق فيبايعونه وينشأ رجل من
قريش أخواله من كلب إليهم جيشا فيهزمونهم ويظهرون
عليهم فيقسم بين الناس فيؤهم ويعمل فيهم وعشرون
نبيهم صلى الله عليه وسلم ويلقى الإسلام بجرانه إلى الأرض
يمكث سبع سنين
"There will be disagreement at the death of a Khilafah, so a man from Madinah will come out fleeing to Makkah, and the people of Makkah will come to him and bring him out (as a claimant for the Khilafah) against his will and swear allegiance to him between the Corner (of the Ka'bah in which the black stone is) and the station (of Ibrahim). An expeditionary force will be sent against him from Sham (Syria) and the earth will swallow them up in the waterless desert between Makkah and Madinah. When people see that, the Abdal of the people of Sham will come to him and the companies of the people of Iraq and they will swear allegiance to him. Then a man of Quraysh will arise (in rebellion) whose maternal uncles are (the tribe of) Kalb, and an expeditionary force will be sent against them and they will conquer them, and that is the expeditionary force of Kalb, and there is disappointment for whoever does not attend (the division of) the spoils of Kalb. So he will divide up the wealth, and he will act among people according to their Prophet's Sunnah and he will throw Islam by its neck on the earth. He will remain seven years then die and the Muslims will pray over him" [Abu Dawud Book 36, Number 427]
Can someone please enlight me about the authenticity of the below metioned hadeeth? I have heard that Ibn al-Qayyim and others have declared it as saheeh but i also have come to know that Al-Albaanee has declared it as Da3eef. Can we say that this hadeeth is weak for positive surety? And are there any other ahadeeth narrated with this wording in other hadeeth collections which would strengthen this narration?
Barak Allahu feekum.
Abu Dawud also published from Umm Salamah by way of Salih Abu'l-Khaleel from a companion of his from Umm Sal amah, that he said,
يكون اختلاف ثم موت خليفة يخرج رجل من قريش من
أهل المدينة إلى مكة فيأتيه ناس من اهل مكة فيخرجونه وهو
كاره فيبايعونه بين الركن والمقام إليه جيشا من أهل الشام
فإذا كانوا بالبيداء خسف بهم فإذا بلغ الناس ذلك أتاه أهل
الشام وعصائب من أهل العراق فيبايعونه وينشأ رجل من
قريش أخواله من كلب إليهم جيشا فيهزمونهم ويظهرون
عليهم فيقسم بين الناس فيؤهم ويعمل فيهم وعشرون
نبيهم صلى الله عليه وسلم ويلقى الإسلام بجرانه إلى الأرض
يمكث سبع سنين
"There will be disagreement at the death of a Khilafah, so a man from Madinah will come out fleeing to Makkah, and the people of Makkah will come to him and bring him out (as a claimant for the Khilafah) against his will and swear allegiance to him between the Corner (of the Ka'bah in which the black stone is) and the station (of Ibrahim). An expeditionary force will be sent against him from Sham (Syria) and the earth will swallow them up in the waterless desert between Makkah and Madinah. When people see that, the Abdal of the people of Sham will come to him and the companies of the people of Iraq and they will swear allegiance to him. Then a man of Quraysh will arise (in rebellion) whose maternal uncles are (the tribe of) Kalb, and an expeditionary force will be sent against them and they will conquer them, and that is the expeditionary force of Kalb, and there is disappointment for whoever does not attend (the division of) the spoils of Kalb. So he will divide up the wealth, and he will act among people according to their Prophet's Sunnah and he will throw Islam by its neck on the earth. He will remain seven years then die and the Muslims will pray over him" [Abu Dawud Book 36, Number 427]