Calling upon Prophet Muhammad, Is it Shirk ? Fazail Amaal explains

[Ibn Saeed]

Assalamaualiakaum

Here are the scanned pages from Fazail Amaal, Charity and Hajj Vol 2.

[hearandobey]

assalamu alaykum,

brother can you upload the pictures here or on an image hosting site, as i'm not registered with facebook. jazakAllahu khayran

[Ibn Saeed]

here is a direct link for Public.

I dont know how to upload to the forum

http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pi...8&id=666805599

[Abdullah Ali al Hanafi]

Assalamaualiakaum

Here are the scanned pages from Fazail Amaal, Charity and Hajj Vol 2.

bro can you briefly explain what the text of the pictures say , does the Fazaail Amaal teach Calling upon Prophet Muhammad?

[hearandobey]

jazakallahu khayran, i was only able to see the book cover's pic.

could someone pls give the bro instructions on how to upload the pics?

[Skillganon]

Register and upload the Image to this site: http://photobucket.com/ That is the site I personally use. It's an image hosting site.

Once Uploaded it would provide you with the URL to share in forum.

[paki_muslim]

It is Shirk.

This is what the third link reads:

From Fazail Hajj.

Story No. 24

Sufi Abu Abdullah Muhamad bin Abi Zar'aa RA relates "May father, Abu Abdullah bin Khafif and I once came to Mecca and in the holy city we suffered great hunger. In that destitute condition we traveled to Madina. We slept without any food on empty stomachs. I was then a mere child and repeatedly complained to my father of the great hunger that I felt. My father then went to the grave of Rasulallah saw and after having greeted him said: "O Rasulallah saw today I am your guest." Having said that my father sat down in meditation. After sitting like that for a short while he lifted up his head and we saw him first crying and then laughing. Someone asked him the reason for his strange behaviour and he replied: "I have seen Rasulallah saw and he gave me a few dirhams. When I opened my hands I found a few dirhams there."

Sufi Abu Abdullah further relates: Allah blessed us so much that with those dirhams we fulfilled our needs till we reached our hometown of Shiraz.

[Abdullah Ali al Hanafi]

It is Shirk.

This is what the third link reads:

From Fazail Hajj.

Story No. 24

Sufi Abu Abdullah Muhamad bin Abi Zar'aa RA relates "May father, Abu Abdullah bin Khafif and I once came to Mecca and in the holy city we suffered great hunger. In that destitute condition we traveled to Madina. We slept without any food on empty stomachs. I was then a mere child and repeatedly complained to my father of the great hunger that I felt. My father then went to the grave of Rasulallah saw and after having greeted him said: "O Rasulallah saw today I am your guest." Having said that my father sat down in meditation. After sitting like that for a short while he lifted up his head and we saw him first crying and then laughing. Someone asked him the reason for his strange behaviour and he replied: "I have seen Rasulallah saw and he gave me a few dirhams. When I opened my hands I found a few dirhams there."

Sufi Abu Abdullah further relates: Allah blessed us so much that with those dirhams we fulfilled our needs till we reached our hometown of Shiraz.

Bareilwis love to narrate such baseless fabricated ''Dreams'' and ''Stories'' , everytime you ask them for daleel , they use such Dreams and Stories , i am aware that this Fazaail Amaal is a Tablighi Book right?

[Ibn Saeed]

SOrry for the wrong Public LInk:

Here is the correct Public Link:
http://www.facebook.com/album.php?ai...5&id=666805599

Yes, Fazail Amaal is Tableghi Book of Deoband.

If the above link does not work, let me know and i will upload to image hosting.

[umar bin khatab]

La hulla wa quwata illa bilallah