New and important arabic book with Audio Sharh about "Aslu din, Udhr bil Jahl,.."

[AbuIman_alMaghrabi]

Assalamu alaikum


كتاب الإسلام وأدلته
http://risalatun.com/kutub/kitabu-l-islam.pdf

Audio Sharh:
ط±ط³ط§ظ„ط© ط§ظ„ط£ظ†ط¨ظٹط§ط، www.risalatun.com

[justabro]

Why exactly is this so important?

[AbuIman_alMaghrabi]

I want to point out (with my bad english) why this Mas`ala is so important

Because of the separation between Tawheed and Shirk, between Muslimin and Mushrikeen.

This clear separation has been lost for many people and there are some argumentative gateways or shubuhat to destroy this basic islamic seperation

Many people think today, this shubuhat allows them to mix Tauheed and Shirk, Haqq with Batil
For example: to get the clear mushrikin or tawgheet into islam,..., even when they accept that they do shirk akbar.
For example: They say, Yes he does shirk akbar, but because of his Jahl he is still a muslim till the huja reached him.

I think this is one of the catastrophic desasters in our times. Not knowing where are the frontiers between a Muslim and a Mushrik.

If you understand arabic then you can study the book with his audio explanation.

I think and hope then you will understand better inshallah

[justabro]

I see. So if we disagree with the author, can we still be Muslims?

[AbuIman_alMaghrabi]

I think that is another Mas`ala.

Is the baraa from the mushrikin a part of Aslu Din?
Or, can someone build up his Islam without the baraa from the mushrikin?

You must search and answer such questions for yourself.
It`s your din and responsibility.

But this Mas`ala is not the subject in this book and i think the author didn`t write anything about this Mas`ala yet.

If you disagree with the explaining or conclusions of the author, it would be nice to explain exactly why?
It would help me, maybe the author, and everybody else to understand the religion better, no matter if you wrong or right... everything could be a help.

[Abu Sulayman]

Assalamu 'alaykum wa rahmatullah,

the guy who wrote the book is Abu Hamzah al-Afghani and this guy has a book in German language with the name "Eine ruhige Kritik an den kaempfenden Gruppen". In that book he makes Takfir upon all Mujahidin of today: Shaykh 'Abdullah 'Azzam (rahimahullah), Amir Khattab (rahimahullah), the Taliban and all other Mujahidin (whom he calls as "kaempfende Gruppen"/the fighting groups).

His older brother (i.e. Abul Khattab) was also one from the Ghulat at-Takfir and then apostisized and became a Rafidhi, but it seems that Abu Hamzah has not learned from that incident.

May Allah ta'ala protect us from such people.

[AbuIman_alMaghrabi]

Assalamu 'alaykum wa rahmatullah,

the guy who wrote the book is Abu Hamzah al-Afghani and this guy has a book in German language with the name "Eine ruhige Kritik an den kaempfenden Gruppen". In that book he makes Takfir upon all Mujahidin of today: Schaykh 'Abdullah 'Azzam (rahimahullah), Amir Khattab (rahimahullah), the Taliban and all other Mujahidin (whom he calls as "kaempfende Gruppen"/the fighting groups).

His older brother (i.e. Abul Khattab) was also one from the Ghulat at-Takfir and then apostisized and became a Rafidhi, but it seems that Abu Hamzah has not learned from that incident.

May Allah ta'ala protect us from such people.

Now, You have to prove your assertion, or you're a liar by the methodes of ahlul sunnah wal djamma3.

He didn`t wrote a single takfir in his book.

He made a "quiet criticism" (that means "Eine ruhige Kritik").
About what? About the same issue "udhr bil Jahl", and i think long before you even knew the existence of this subject in germany.

For blind followers of holy mens maybe a quiet criticism about a few people means for them a takfir against the whole planet,
but the truth is: Nowhere in his book he made one single takfir against anybody.

He only points out (that was the quiet criticism) that some people on the djihadi Manhaj have the same opinion like many other groups,
namely that a clear mushrik can be a muslim for them, because of their Jahl, thats all.

Is this a right Opinon for you Abu Sulayman ? Is this your djihad for the truth? Is this your islamic righteousness for Allah (t)?

So either Abu Sulayman you can not read exactly, or you are a liar who can not stop lying even during ramadan, Allahu Mustaan

May Allah ta'ala protect us from such ignorant people and false dirty methods

[abuhannah]

"Can you see what it is yet?"....

Rolf Harris

[Abu Sulayman]

He made a "quiet criticism" (that means "Eine ruhige Kritik").
About what? About the same issue "udhr bil Jahl", and i think long before you even knew the existence of this subject in germany.

For blind followers of holy mens maybe a quiet criticism about a few people means for them a takfir against the whole planet,
but the truth is: Nowhere in his book he made one single takfir against anybody.

Okay, let's say I and almost everyone who has heard about him has misunderstood him.

I've a very simple question: Do you regard the Taliban as muslims? Yes or no?

And I gave a salam, but you didn't respond to that. Why? Am I not a muslim for you?

Was someone like Shaykh Ibn 'Uthaymin (rahimahullah) a muslim?

Was Shaykh 'Abdullah 'Azzam (rahimahullah) a muslim?

[Abdul Malik]

On what grounds can the Taliban be Kuffar? Do they believe in shirk or something ? Defending their territory can never be kufr akbar.