Rabee al-Madkhali: Architect of the "Jarh wal-Ghiba" Cult

**justabro** · 5th July 2008

Assalamu alaykum wa rahmatullah

I think it is high time that there be an extensive refutation of Rabee al-Madkhali in English. I think this should be a cooperative effort, as it's simply not worth any one person wasting all their time to gather all the material. Let's try and keep this thread focused on gathering substantive materials that is available against him, etc. as there are plenty of other threads if people just want to discuss or give their viewpoints.

Everyone is welcome to contribute, and those who have questions are welcome to ask questions about his "manhaj".

A Note on How to Benefit from This Thread:
Ignore Ali's posts and the responses to him and continue reading

**Hamza** · 5th July 2008

I would like a clarification on this specific allegation against the shaheed; Syed Qutb.

1. What did Syed mean when he was writing about "excitable folk" with regards to Musa as. ?

**Wild Wild West** · 5th July 2008

Originally Posted by justabro

Assalamu alaykum wa rahmatullah

I think it is high time that there be an extensive refutation of Rabee al-Madkhali in English. I think this should be a cooperative effort, as it's simply not worth any one person wasting all their time to gather all the material. Let's try and keep this thread focused on gathering substantive materials that is available against him, etc. as there are plenty of other threads if people just want to discuss or give their viewpoints.

Everyone is welcome to contribute, and those who have questions are welcome to ask questions about his "manhaj".

I can't believe you have done this!

But seeing as you have, I think you should start off with who he is, what he has done (good and bad), what 'madkhalism' is, how it has so many offshoots, the damage it has done to the da'wah, and then, finally, a proposed solution to the crisis...

you would well be worth a phd by that time...

**hearandobey** · 5th July 2008

jazakAllahu khayran for this.

what would you say about some of the things said about sayid qutb's tafsir here? some of the quotes are taken from rabi's book.

**Abu Sabaya** · 5th July 2008

'Alaykum as-Salam wa Rahmatullah wa Barakatuh;

Go to al-Ma'ribi's website, he has a number of refutations of Rabi' written up:

الجواب البديع في رد بعض تشنيعات الشيخ ربيع
تحذير الجميع من أخطاء الشيخ ربيع وأسلوبه الشنيع
إعلان النكير على منهج الشيخ ربيع في التكفير
القول المفحم لمن أنكر مقالة "نصحح ولا نهدم" رد على الشيخ ربيع المدخلي

Revenge, I guess.

**Abu Faaris Al-Atharee** · 5th July 2008

This page was put together buy some brothers who have a deep interest( or addiction) in refuting rabee' al-Madkhali.

http://www.alathary.org/rabee/

**Madarijas-Salikeen** · 5th July 2008

Translations are in dire need!

**Expergefactionist** · 5th July 2008

JK justabro! Much needed thread. Hopefully, it would be of as much benefit as the threads we have on Ash'aris.

**Allah Diya** · 5th July 2008

You can never refute him, alhamdulillah, he had an excellent understanding of the manhaj of this religion, not to mention his mastery of aqeeda related issues. All your endeavors will prove to be futile and wasted with regard to refuting the Imam of Jarh wa't tadeel.

**Madarijas-Salikeen** · 5th July 2008

as salaamu alaykum,

abuz zubayr what would be the view on shaykh rabee? The reason i ask is because we see some praise by shaykh al albaani rahimahullah ibn uthaymeen rahimahullah and others of shaykh rabee. But then again we have other ulama warning him about his harshness and injustice when criticizing individuals