Umar bin Abdul Aziz

[Zhulfiqar]

Umar bin Abdul Aziz "RadieAllahoe Anhoe" returned the Fadak to the progeny of Fatima "RadieAllahoe Anha" is this true ? Can brothers maybe show hadiths of it or any other proof for it why he did.

[leo]

Not important at all. It may be viewed as personal act/decision of Umar bin Abdul Aziz (may Allah be pleased with him).

The most important to be noted is the decision of Ali (RA):-

Sayyid Murtada (known as ‘Alam al-Huda) narrates in his book on Imamah entitled ash-Shafi, that when ‘Ali became the khalifah he was approached about returning Fadak. His reply was: “I am ashamed before Allah to overturn something that was prohibited by Abu Bakr and continued by ‘Umar.” (al-Murtada, ash-Shafi fil-Imamah, p. 231; and Ibn Abil Hadid, Sharh Nahj al-Balaghah, vol. 4)

We know, rafida try to take advantage by defaming Abu Bakr (RA) and Umar (RA) and when we ask them to show us any evidence about reversal of the decision by Abu bakr (RA) during caliphate of Ali (RA), they become mute and don't have any answer to offer.

[Muslim4life101]

1th imam of shiasm did not return fadak to ahlebeyt when he had the chance
4th imam accepts fadak from caliph

the weak arguments of shias towards ali's decision: ahlebeyt dont take back usurped rights, ali was under taqiyyah.