Re: Evidence for dogs being impure?

Originally Posted by
Mufakkir
If there was a reason for the washing. Rasulullah [saw] would have given it. Like the hadith about a fly falling into your vessel. Rasulullah [saw] said to dip it in fully. Reason being one wing has the disease. It is given within the hadith itself.
I didn't think of it like that, good point
Angels do not enter not because of impurity. They do not enter because of pictures also. Pictures are not impure. This is conflicting though. Mother Aisha [ra] had made cushions out of curtains. The curtains had pictures on them. Which means there were pictures in the house still.
There is no underlying cause. The act is a simple worship.
Pictures of living things are generally considered haraam, there are different narrations about that but it doesn't mean something being haraam is najas
If someone has any reports from the Sahabah [ra]. Showing they considered dogs impure. This would be helpful.
If there were this would end by now
"Sheikh said..." - Wrong path
"Allaah, Rasool said..." - Right path
Don't base your Deen on the popularity of a scholar
Bookmarks