Imaam Ahmads treatise on Salah

[moubeen]

Assalamu'alaykum,

"Imaam Ahmads treatise on Salah"

does anyone know where this treatise can be purchased in arabic.

I've seen an english translation by Sameh Strauch... but it is not well referanced. Does nayone know about the arabic booklet?

[Expergefactionist]

I am sure you should be able to download it from somewhere.

[justabro]

wa alaykum assalam

hope this helps:

http://almeshkat.net/books/open.php?cat=32&book=2161

[justabro]

and this:

http://www.ahlalhdeeth.com/vb/showthread.php?t=79890

[Abu Maryam PK]

I remember some senior scholars have said this book is not authentically attributed to Imam Ahmed. It is a fabrication on him. Wallahu A'alam

[Expergefactionist]

And many others have authentically attributed the work to Imam Ahmad. See Sh Bakr's Madkhal

[Umm Ahmed]

I remember some senior scholars have said this book is not authentically attributed to Imam Ahmed. It is a fabrication on him. Wallahu A'alam

You can ask further, and inshaAllaah obtain a clarification for us all , by e-mailing iiph@iiph.com.sa they are the ones who published the translation.

[Abu'l 'Eyse]

so is it a good reference?

[أبو نافع]

Ibn Taymiyyah accepted it as his, as he did with some other 'obscure' writings. I believe it is his, except that it does contain some anachronic elements if I recall correctly? Something like some Rasa'il mention in al-Umm of al-Shafi'i.

[Madarijas-Salikeen]

as salaamu alaykum,.

imagine an extremist saying 'astaghfirallah imam ahmad allows also placing hands below naval?'

Im wonder if many are even aware of imam ahmad's treatise. Ive seen it on a Salafi site, would be interesting to know what others who are la madhabi would think of the positions. Perhaps they'd think themselves more learned