This is a discussion on Useless Rambling within the Islam in General forums, part of the Main Topics category; nobody because this title is nothing more than a facad. The most probable and logical conclusion as to why al-Albanee ...
- 14th July 2008 #1
nobody because this title is nothing more than a facad. The most probable and logical conclusion as to why al-Albanee was the only one to refer to Shaykh Rabee in this fashion seems that it has to do more with the fact that Rabee was at the head (among all else) to be refuting other people. That would only sound more likely as none has reached the amount of refutations of others as Rabee has done which is why al-Alabanee marks the point tat he is known for criticising and warning.
The other statement that is overshadowed in the midst of the mistranslated title as being "Imaam of jarh" is when al-Albanee commented on his rather extreme or harsh overkills in his refutations advising him to take a more milder (objective or moderate) approach. But this qualifiying statment goes unoticed to this day unfortunately.
- 14th July 2008 #2
- 14th July 2008 #3
- 14th July 2008 #4
- Join Date
- Jul 2004
- 23rd July 2008 #5
so Muqbil is now a madhkhalee
I suppose Abu Hasan can be thrown in that.
so now we have
are all madkhalis because they all share of what you deem as the "same world view" as Rabee. The only problem is you don't want to call Muqbil and al-Albanee as "madkhalis" or else your entire bidi theory of the madkhali sect phenomenon goes out the window.
All of this because you are reading more into Rabee than what he actually is. He is an old man on medication and known for being too extreme and lacks some adl in his refutations.
thats what he is.
adding to that his positions on kufr and jihaad is commenting on the whole of sunnism which is why you are left with linking Mubil and other sunni scholars as being "like" madkhali when in fat it is nothing other than salafiyyah.
- 23rd July 2008 #6
- Join Date
- Aug 2006
oh oh Ali's prescriptions of pain killers ran out again!
Everyone knows Muqbil was a Khariji to you guys untill he went back on what he said about Saudi gov, and everyone knows he only did that because he wanted to go to Hajj before he died and other pressures they put on him.
- 23rd July 2008 #7
Everyone knows Muqbil was a Khariji to you guys untill he went back on what he said about Saudi gov, and everyone knows he only did that because he wanted to go to Hajj before he died and other pressures they put on him....and Allah has preferred the Mujahideen above those who sit by a huge reward - An Nisaa 95
- 23rd July 2008 #8
- 25th July 2008 #9
May Allah have mercy on Shaykh Muqbli. He died without haveing any hatred for those who establish the tawheed of Allah, eradicate the shirk with Allah, and implement the tashree of Allah
if you did not get haakimyyah as part of the tawheed of Allah in that, then I can see where halaawism lands a person to. idiocy
- 25th July 2008 #10Originally Posted by ali
Saudi Arabia even recognised Taliban as a legitimate Shara'i government. What drugs are you on, apart from the obvious Madkhali weed.A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new.