Results 1 to 1 of 1

Sunni responses to anti-Sunni sectarian polemics

This is a discussion on Sunni responses to anti-Sunni sectarian polemics within the Islamic Groups and Sects forums, part of the Islamic Theology and Ideology category; Note: If you wish to submit a thread or post here, contact the admins by PM and they will consider. ...

  1. #1
    Peculiarly Ostrobogulous Expergefactionist's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Londonistan
    Posts
    13,421
    Follow Expergefactionist On Twitter Add Expergefactionist on Facebook Add Expergefactionist on Google+

    Default Sunni responses to anti-Sunni sectarian polemics

    Note: If you wish to submit a thread or post here, contact the admins by PM and they will consider.

    Imam Ahmad

    Imam Ahmad and Tafwid

    Are Hanbalis and Salafis the same? - Page 2

    Ta'wil of 'Your Lord Will Come...'
    Are Hanbalis and Salafis the same? - Page 7

    The creed of Imam Ahmad is what's transmitted, preserved and published in the following literature.
    "Imam Ahmad is a Mushabbih" - who will follow?

    On the issue of al-Radd 'Ala al-Jahmiyyah being penned by Imam Ahmad Bin Hanbal
    Attribution of Kitab Radd 'ala Jahmiyyah to Imaam Ahmad

    Kitab al-Sunnah by 'Abdullah b. Ahmad b. Hanbal
    Are Hanbalis and Salafis the same? - Page 6



    'Uthman b. Sa'id al-Darimi

    Killing off the Ash'arite disregard for Shaykh 'Uthman b. Sa'id al-Darimi
    How the Shafi'ites washed their hands off.. from Ash'arism!

    The Mosquito accusation against Imams Darimi and Ibn Taymiyya
    African American Asharis 'refuting' Salafism in Philly!! - Page 8
    How the Shafi'ites washed their hands off.. from Ash'arism! - Page 11

    'Uthman b. Sa'id al-Darimi in the eyes of Ibn 'Asakir.
    Board Message (cache)
    Imam of the Salafis


    Ibn Qudamah

    Ibn Qudamah and Tafwid
    Are Hanbalis and Salafis the same? - Page 2

    Ibn Qudamah and the term Zahir
    Tafwid al-Ma`na (yes, again)



    Ibn Taymiyyah

    Was Ibn Taymiyyah a Sufi?
    Sunnipress -> Ibn Taymiyyah the Sufi ??

    What are Ibn Taymiyyah's Credentials?
    Board Message

    Ibn Taymiyyah's Debate with the Ash'arites: al-Munazarah al-Wasitiyyah.
    Sunnipress -> Sarh 'Aqida al-Wasitiyyah

    The Sources of 'Aqidah al-Hamawiyyah
    Sunnipress -> The Sources of Aqidah al-Hamawiyyah

    Badr 'l-Din al-`Ayni al-Hanafi on Ibn Taymiyyah
    http://forums.islamicawakening.com/f...-hanafi-67767/

    Refutation of kalami points of Ibn Sina (Avicenna) Taken from Dar at-Ta'arud al-'Aql wal-Naql
    Destroying Jahmiyyah Mu'atilla. Ibn Taymiyyah Vs. Ibn Sina

    The Creed of the Early Sufis - Ibn Taymiyyah Expounds
    The creed of Imam Junayd. - Page 2

    The issue of infinite regress, and Allah's attributes being connected to His Will
    ALLAHS ATTRIBUTES-SOME CLARIFICATION
    Questions by HS to HH (posts 133-175)
    Perpetual Creativity in the perfection of God: Ibn Taymiyyah's Hadith commentary on G



    Ibn Kathir

    On the attributes

    Are Hanbalis and Salafis the same? - Page 6

    Ibn Kathir and differentiation between a Shafi'ite and an Ash'arite
    How the Shafi'ites washed their hands off.. from Ash'arism!

    The way in which Ibn Kathir affirmed the Sifat and what he attributed to the salaf as-salih
    Tafwid of ibn kathir - Page 6

    Al-Hafidh al-Dhahabi's "retraction" of al-'Uluww and some matters related to Ibn Kathir's supposed "Tafwid"
    Tafwid of ibn kathir

    The supposed Tafwid of Al-Hafidh Ibn Kathir and his "declaration" of Ash'arism
    Tafwid of ibn kathir - Page 3
    Tafwid of ibn kathir - Page 4



    Al-Saffarini
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned

    On Allah's Elevation, Rising and Direction
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned

    On Tafwidh and the Literal Meaning (Zahir)
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned

    On the Eternal, Eternal Attributes, parts and divisibility
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned

    On Quran, Sound and Letters
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned

    On substance (jawhar), accident ('aradh) and body (jism)
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned

    On affirming Allah's Face
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned

    On Allah's Hands
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned

    On Allah's Eye and Tafwid of Tahdid (definition)
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned

    On Allah's Descent
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned

    Takhliq and Takwin, between Hanbalis, Maturidis and Ash'aris
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned - Page 2

    Eternal, temporal and comments by Salafi editors
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned - Page 2

    Conclusion
    Rotten ‘Apples and Oranges’: Goods Returned - Page 2



    Hanbalites

    The Books on Creed by the Hanabilah
    Sunnipress -> Imam Ahmad Aqida vs Pseudo-Hanbali

    Classical Hanbalite Manuals on Creed & Theology
    Board Message

    Classical Hanbalite Manuals on the Principles of Jurisprudence and related works
    Board Message

    The Classes of Hanbalites
    Board Message

    Qadi Abu Ya'la and his son Ibn Abi Ya'la reject Tashbih & Tasjim
    Qur'an Wa Sunnah -> Are We Anthorpomorphists?

    Short Notice on Qadi Abu Ya'la b. al-Farra'
    Board Message



    Other scholars

    Did Imam al-Shafi`i categorise `Ilm 'l-Kalam into good and bad, or did he condemn it wholly?

    1. Questions by HS to HH
    2. Questions by HS to HH
    3. Questions by HS to HH
    4. Questions by HS to HH


    On the Authenticity of Abu Bakr al-Isma'ili's Book: 'Itiqad A'immat al-Hadith.
    Board Message

    Abu 'Ali al-Ahwazi: an early critic of Ash'arism.
    Board Message

    Ibn 'Aqil refuting the Ash'arites
    Ibn 'Aqil's Refutation of Ash'arites

    Ibn Nasir, the teacher of Ibn al-Jawziy and his turn from Ash'arism to Sunnism
    He told me: "be on the madhhab of Imam Ahmad and Ashab al-Hadith in Usool (aqeedah)
    Shaykh 'Abdul-Qadir al-Jilaani al-hanbali(rh) on al-Istiwa!

    Ibn al-Jawzi: A Lifetime of Da'wah
    IslamicAwakening.Com: Ibn al-Jawzi: A Lifetime of Da'wah

    On al-Nawawi's perceived Ash'arism
    Multaqa Ahl al-Hadeeth

    Imam al-Mizzi’s imprisonment at the hands of Ash`aris
    http://forums.islamicawakening.com/f...is-book-24751/

    Regarding al-Karmi and his book Aqawil al-Thiqat
    Are Hanbalis and Salafis the same? - Page 4

    Shafi'i Imams there were Athari in Aqidah
    shafiyyah ashariyyah or shafiyyah ahluh sunnah?

    How the Shafi'ites washed their hands off from the Ash'arite Madhhab
    How the Shafi'ites washed their hands off.. from Ash'arism!

    Classical Hanafis who actively promoted Atharism
    Ahlul Athar Hanafis? (prev: Hanafi Salafis?)



    Abul Hasan al-Ash'ari

    Abu'l-Hasan al-Ash'ari between Praise and Dispraise.
    Sunnipress -> Judgement on al-Ash'ari..?

    Abu'l-Hasan al-Ash'ari on Kalam in one of his final books.
    Sunnipress -> Imam al-Ash'ari on Kalam

    On the Isnad of the Ibanah.
    Sunnipress -> Ash'ari's Ibanah: where is its Sanad? Is it his?

    Issues pertaining to the authenticity of al-Ibanah of al-Ash'ari in particular the issue of 'ayn/'aynayn
    ahya.org • View topic - Abu'l-Hasan al-Ash'ari affirms 'Aynayn/Two Eyes

    Abu'l Hasan al-Ash'ari affirming Sifat 'Ala al-Haqiqah
    Haadir Naadir - Page 2



    Ibn Kullab

    Introduction to Ibn Kullab & the Kullabiyyah.
    Sunnipress -> Introduction to Ibn Kullab & Kullabiyyah



    Abu Mansur al-Maturidi

    Who is al-Maturidi?
    Sunnipress -> Who are the Maturidiyyah?



    Ash'arites

    Criticism of Ash'arism by Early and Later Scholars.
    Sunnipress -> Important Studies on Ash'arism

    Is the Sufi Ibn 'Arabi an Ash'arite?
    Sunnipress -> Problem with Ibnul-Arabi

    Some Important Ash'arite Texts.
    Some Important Ash'arite Texts

    Are Asharis the saved sect? Which Asharis???
    Multaqa Ahl al-Hadeeth

    Asharite view on prophets being alive
    Asharite view on prophets being alive?



    Maturidites

    On the Authenticity of al-Fiqh al-Akbar.
    Sunnipress -> The Fiqh al-Akbar by Pseudo-Abu Hanifah

    Some Important Hanafite-Maturidite Texts.
    Sunnipress -> Some Important Hanafite-Maturidite Texts

    The menace of Zahid al-Kawthari
    al-Kawthari: Imam of the Jahmiyyah



    Does Ash`arism it dominate the Muslim Ummah?

    Did Ash'arism dominate Islamic history?
    The Peecieved Dominance of the Ash'ari Madhhab

    Getting Rid of the Perceived Numerical Dominance of Ash'arites
    Getting Rid of the Preceived Dominiance of Ash'arites: to Beyonder et al.

    Ash`aris are not the majority of the Ummah; in fact they despise the creed of lay Muslims
    http://forums.islamicawakening.com/f...beliefs-70134/

    An empirical study of how many scholars in the Ummah were Sunni and how many were Mutakallimun
    Scholars of Dhahir Vs Scholars of Ta'weel



    Salafis

    Summary of the Deviation of the Madkhali Salafiyyah
    Summary of the Deviation of the Madkhalee 'Salafiyyah'.

    A Detailed Ongoing Analysis on Rabi' al-Madkhali and His Cult
    Refutation of Rabee al-Madkhali: Architect of the "Jarh wal-Ta'dil" Cult



    Tawhid of Uluhiyyah, Istighathah, Tawassul, etc.

    The Mushrikun Affirmed Allah's Rububiyyah - The Ash'ari Imams Razi and Qurtubi as opposed to Alawi al Maliki
    The Mushrikeen affirmed Allah's Ruboobiyya( Lordship)

    Imam Razi: The Mushrikun and the glorifiers of the grave are similar
    Razi on those who seek intercession of the dead

    All about Istighatha, Istishfa', and Tawassul, etc...
    All about Istighatha, Istishfa', and Tawassul, etc...

    Hanafis on Istighathah
    A true hanafi refutes faqir

    On Subki and Tawassul/Istighatha
    "No to imported Islam, yes to the Islam of our parents," read one banner

    Discussion on the Hadith of Malik ad-Dar
    Did Ibn Hajar support isthigatha from dead ??!!
    Narration of Malik al Dar >evidence for tawassul by the living & not through the dead



    Tawhid of Asma and Sifat

    The Salaf on Affirming the Sifat and negating its resemblance to the creation
    Who was....
    Who was....
    Who was....
    Who was....
    Who was....
    Who was....Who was.... - Page 2


    Zahir and Mutashabih
    Are Hanbalis and Salafis the same? - Page 3
    Are Hanbalis and Salafis the same? - Page 6

    Attributes and Balagha between Sunni and Jahmi linguists
    God's beautiful body. - Page 7
    God's beautiful body. - Page 7

    Verses and Traditions that appear blasphemous to Ash’ari heretics
    God's beautiful body. - Page 7

    The Tafwid of the Salaf al-Salih
    Sunnipress -> The 'Tafwid' of the Salaf al-Salih

    The Salaf took the Attributes according to their Zahir Meaning.
    Sunnipress -> The Attributes of Allah - According to the Salaf

    Issues pertaining to Allah Ta'ala's actions and the Qur'an
    Issues pertaining to ALLAH Ta'ala's actions and The Qur'an

    Imam al Baghawi on Istiwa'
    Tafaseer on Al-Istiwa 7:54

    Imam Abdul Qadir al Jilani on Istiwa'
    Shaykh 'Abdul-Qadir al-Jilaani al-hanbali(rh) on al-Istiwa!

    Imam al-Dhahabi and the issue of 2 hands
    Imam al-Dhahabi on Allah's Hands

    Replying to claim that al-Bukhari made Tawil of "laughter" to mean "mercy"
    Multaqa Ahl al-Hadeeth

    Did Imam al-Bukhari have the opinion that "wajh" in ayah (28:28) means Mulk- Dominion, thus making Ta'wil of it ?
    Did Imam al Bukhari have the opinion that “wajh” in ayah (28:88) means Mulk – Dominion, thus making ta’wil of it? | Topics and Replies

    Refutation: NHM Keller's weakeing of "Where is Allah" Hadith
    Multaqa Ahl al-Hadeeth

    Imam Qurtubi in defence of Imam Ibn Abd al-Barr regarding Allah being above the throne
    Imam Qurtubi in defence of Imam Ibn Abd alBar regarding Allah being above the throne

    The explanation of the hadith in which the Prophet narrates Allah saying (And I am the dahr [time])
    what is to be taken literally/metaphorically in the quran? - Page 2

    Was it the Belief of The Pharaoh or Musa, That Allah is Above the Heavens?
    Multaqa Ahl al-Hadeeth

    Dissecting Aristotelianism From Its Roots Using the Divine Logic Found in The Quran and the Kalam of Rasulullah
    Aristotle's Logic In Light of Quraan and Sunnah

    Muhammad Anwar Shah Kashmiri on passing the attributes of Allah upon its Zahir - apparent meanings
    Muhammad Anwar Shah Kashmiri and passing the texts of Sifat on its Zahir

    Al-Qurtubi and the issue of al-Istiwa'
    Imam Qurtubi in defence of Imam Ibn Abd alBar regarding Allah being above the throne

    Ibn Hajar al Asqalani refutes the tafwid al ma'na by the Salaf
    Allahu Akbar! Ibn Hajar refutes the claim that Salaf did tafwid al ma'na

    Al-Tabari and the attributes of Allah Ta'ala
    Multaqa Ahl al-Hadeeth



    The Kalam of Allah and the Quran: Ahl 'l-Sunnah v. Ahl 'l-Kalam

    Maturidites and the Qur'an
    The Maturidis believe: The Qur'an is created

    Asharites and the Qur'an
    The Ash'aris believe: The Quran is created

    Muhammad Abu Zahra al-Azhari al-Ash'ari: The Mu'tazilah are upon the truth and Imam Ahmad was incorrect in relation to their debate pertaining the the Qur'an and it being created or not!
    Abu Zahra al-Ash'ari: Mu'tazila were right, Ahmad b. Hanbal was wrong! - Page 2

    Nearly 50 contemporaries of Imam Ahmad and after him Affirm Letters for Allah's Speech
    Is Speech made up of Sounds and Letters - Page 18

    The issue of our recitation being created or uncreated
    ahadith required

    The Lafz of the Qur'an: created or uncreated, between the Imams of the Ahl al-Sunnah

    1. Preliminary Introduction: short history of how the Qur'an was understood (summary, unfinished)
    2. The Lafz in the Beginning: al-Karabisi's innovation and the innovation of Ahmad al-Sharak (summary, unfinished)
    3. The Lafz after al-Karabisi: the differences among the Sunnites (summary, unfinished)
    4. Imam Ahmad's Rejection of the Lafziyyah al-Muthbitah (complete)
    5. The Case of al-Bukhari (unfinished)

    http://forums.islamicawakening.com/a...0&d=1233009509



    Regarding Hadd, Makan, etc.

    Affirming and negating Hadd (ÍÏ), for and from Allah: Ahl 'l-Sunnah v. Ash`aris

    Questions by HS to HH (posts 41-124, interspersed)

    "Allah Exists Without a Place" - REFUTED
    Important "Allah Exists Without a Place" - REFUTED

    Early scholars who used the term Makan to describe the `Uluww of Allah
    Questions by HS to HH (posts 35-73, interspersed)

    Refuting the Ash`ari allegation: "Ibn Jarir, Ibn Battah and Ibn Khuzaymah agreed with Ash`aris on Muhdath = Makhluq"
    Questions by HS to HH (posts 121-130)

    Mutakallimun who agreed with the Sunnis on the concept of Huduth in the actions of Allah
    Questions by HS to HH



    Excuse for ignorance in matters of fundamentals
    question about takfeer
    Announcement Abu Usama on udhur bi jahl
    Announcement Abu Usama on udhur bi jahl
    Sheikh Yasir Qadhi on Shi'ah belief - Page 10
    George Galloway on Israel - Page 16
    Sheikh Yasir Qadhi on Shi'ah belief - Page 3
    Usama Hasan at Quilliam ( he's a Wahabi Sufi he says??) - Page 25



    Resources for refuting Ahl al-Bid'ah
    Sunnipress -> The Ash'ariyyah & Kullabiyyah
    ahya.org • View forum - Discussions / Refutations on the Asha'aree and Matureedee Aqeedah
    Aqeedah 202 | Saheefah


    Miscellaneous

    Destruction of Secularism
    Usama Hasan at Quilliam ( he's a Wahabi Sufi he says??) - Page 11

    Polyandry in Paradise? Refutation of the Neo-Feminists
    Part 1
    Part 2
    Part 3
    Part 4

    The fraudulent Ijazah culture of Ash`aris
    http://forums.islamicawakening.com/f...oraries-23134/

    Debunking the modernist myth of the existence of a 'third' abode apart from Dar 'l-Islam and Dar 'l-Harb
    Yasir Qadhi - The Case of the Swiss Minarets

    Historical Background to Orthodoxy v. Rationalism
    A Study of al-Durra al-Mudhiyya fi ‘Aqidat al-Firqa al-Mardhiyya
    Last edited by Ismail Ibrahim; 3 Weeks Ago at 05:10 PM.
    A person who never made a mistake never tried anything new.

    Albert Einstein


Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41